Business, finance & technology news
Business

Neet and tidy: Milburn’s joblessness plan is plausibly presented, but will it work?

Tories stay away as former Labour minister outlines proposal to save £200m from benefits bill and get young people into employment Ed Cumming Show biography Ed Cumming is a senior feature writer and columnist who started at the Telegraph in 2009, left in 2014…

Neet and tidy: Milburn’s joblessness plan is plausibly presented, but will it work?

Tories stay away as former Labour minister outlines proposal to save £200m from benefits bill and get young people into employment Ed Cumming Show biography Ed Cumming is a senior feature writer and columnist who started at the Telegraph in 2009, left in 2014 and came back in 2022 after a stint in the Left-wing press. His recent interviewees have included Jeremy Clarkson, Anna Wintour and Danny Dyer. He has never won a prize.

Published 17 November 2026 5:54pm GMT Like one of those celebrity memoirs in which all the score-settling and sex scandal has been serialised in the tabloids beforehand, Alan Milburn’s long-heralded Neets review didn’t hold many surprises when it was finally released. This thing has been more trailed than Oregon. The bigger shock was seeing a former politician with a grasp of his material, a plausible manner and an admirable goal: getting the rate of Neets down from 15 per cent to 5 per cent.

“Half-measures will not do,” he said at his press conference. It was only fair that the lesser-spotted Pat McFadden got to deliver the Government’s response in the Commons. Neat, bald, and with that firm-yet-fair Glaswegian manner, McFadden is the most headmasterly of the Cabinet ministers.

It is easy to imagine his quiet fury after busting you smoking in school uniform. On his right-hand side was the Prime Minister, who later said he wanted the review to be a “watershed” moment. Presumably he was in Parliament to lend moral support but, in a black suit and dark grey tie, he looked more like a bouncer.

Like a disappointed Glaswegian headmaster: Pat McFadden Credit : Press Association/House of Commons “There is a narrative out there that describes young people as snowflakes and shirkers, we reject that entirely,” McFadden said, welcoming Milburn’s work. The knights who say Neet were here, and they required a sacrifice. To rectify matters, he had a pile of measures to encourage young people into the workplace.

Among them, the Government would be establishing a Youth Opportunities Unit. The idea is that young people will have a single port of call for Opportunities, whatever those might be. If all else fails, and the young people can’t find an Opportunity in time, the Government will pay businesses to give them a job for six months.

It’s all well-meaning and complicated. Milburn’s report is nearly 300 pages. Will it work?

Perhaps Britain’s benighted Neets really have been yearning for a Youth Opportunities Unit. In my experience, young people mostly want money. In this regard they are similar to adults.

If a job is what it will take to get money, then so be it. But most people, being rational actors, find a way of getting as much money as possible while working as little as possible. Repeated increases to the minimum wage, NI and rates have made it less appealing for businesses to employ young people, just as AI has come along to do their jobs better than them.

But you can’t cut the minimum wage. It is not the Labour way. After all, it was McFadden who observed, in a WhatsApp to Keir Starmer, that “every meeting I have is ‘ Who can we tax in order to pay benefits to others?’” Milburn had cunningly calibrated his review not to save too much money: £200m, to be specific, a conveniently small and round number.

You wouldn’t want an increase in youth employment to improve the public finances: the Labour backbenchers would be in uproar. Replying for the Tories, Helen Whately argued that Labour was merely copying Conservative proposals, before she criticised them anyway. McFadden spotted the opening.

“In the space of a few minutes, she told the House that Alan Milburn has copied the Conservative plan, and also that the plan is reckless Labour spending money,” he said, getting a big laugh. It did not help Whately’s case that hardly any Tories had bothered to turn up. Perhaps they were all out educating, employing and training young people.

Luckily there is another solution. Grand Theft Auto VI is out this week . To judge by the headlines, every young person in the country will be playing it, employed or otherwise.

Don’t listen to critics who try to say the game revels in violent crime: at heart it celebrates entrepreneurship, drive and ambition. Labour should just re-label it as an online training course. A Neet solution.

Source: The Telegraph

Distributed to Daily Terminal by RedPress.

Related News

Contact Advertise Search RSS